Mike Piazza

If you don't want to MLB The Show 25 Stubs drop major stubs on top-tier catchers, Piazza gives you elite hitting tools for cheap. Power bat with a swing that's smoother than ever, and you can usually scoop him for under 20 K. Solid quirks and value.

Anthony Santander (New Threads Collection)

A switch hitter with positional flexibility, strong quirks, and a deadly swing. While he's starting to fall behind top-tier bats, his versatility and switch-side power still keep him relevant, especially if you're building around Blue Jays captains.

Dustin May (Program Reward)

Glitchy mechanics. Glitched release. Glitched effectiveness. May's outlier sinker and funky delivery make him a nightmare to face, even if his hits-per-9 are starting to trail top-tier starters. Every elite rotation has him.

Jason Domínguez

Domínguez is a free card that hits like a premium reward. His defense is spotty, but 110 clutch and elite splits vs righties make him a must-have bat. Small strike zone and quick swing make him elite for the Hall of Fame and MLB The Show 25 Stubs for sale up.